Review of the Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff

I received this book for free from Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Review of the Replacement by Brenna YovanoffThe Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff
Published by Simon and Schuster on 2011-01-06
Genres: Young Adult
Pages: 384
Format: ARC
Source: Publisher
Buy on Amazon

Though he lives in the small town of Gentry, Mackie comes from a world of tunnels and black, murky water, a world of living dead girls ruled by a little tattoed princess. He is a replacement - left in the crib of a human baby sixteen years ago when it was stolen away by the fey. Now, because of fatal allergies to iron, blood and consecrated ground, Mackie is slowly dying in the human world. Mackie would give anything just to be normal, to live quietly amongst humans, practice his bass guitar and spend time with his crush, Tate. But when Tate's baby sister goes missing, Mackie is drawn irrevocably into the underworld of Gentry, known as Mayhem, where he must face down the dark creatures and find his rightful place - in our world, or theirs.

I love it when a book that intends to be creepy is legitimately creepy and not contrived creepy. (Sidebar: just how many times can I use the word creepy in one sentence?) The Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff is an eerie coming of age tale. Mackie Doyle is a replacement aka a changeling, meaning that he has taken the place of a kidnapped child. Mackie is a 16 year old boy with an aversion to iron and blood. He is dying. We see him yearn for a life of normalcy. Yet, the underworld of Gentry, where Mackie came from, comes calling when they steal Mackie’s friend-girl’s baby sister.

At first, I was not sure how much I would enjoy The Replacement by Brenna Yovanoff. You know how sometimes it can take a bit to get into a book? It took me probably 50 pages to really sink into the plot. Despite the slow start, on the whole, I loved The Replacement. I am a fan of macabre books. Hello, Stephen King fangirl right here. I think Yovanoff does atmosphere right. There is such an air of ghoulishness throughout this book that I often got the chills while reading it. I mean, Gentry is a regular small town, much like where I grew up. However, they have a deep dark secret. Unraveling the layers and going deeper and deeper into Gentry’s secrets is incredibly creepy. I can’t help thinking the phrase, ‘Something Wicked This Way Comes’ (also a book by Ray Bradbury).

Mackie, the lead, is irresistable. He’s vulnerable. He’s prone to low self-esteem. He likes boobs (can I get an AMEN for a non-sanitized boy character). He is shown to have deep emotions. I really loved the character of Mackie. I thought he was the sort of character I would have loved as a teen, someone who questions himself and the world around him. His weaknesses are balanced out with his strengths.

Tate, the female lead, is the sort of girl I wish I could have been in high school. She doesn’t give a shit about what anyone thinks of her. She’s so self-assured. I love that. I love seeing a self-assured girl from a male point a view, as this story is told through Mackie’s eyes.

Then of course, the cast of supporting characters is steller. From Mackie’s best friend Roswell, who is everything a friend should be, to the twins, to Mackie’s sister, Emma, these characters I felt were well-rounded. I thought I had a good sense of these characters. I rarely questioned their motives.

The characters of the underworld were scary! HOLY CRAP. There’s this character referred to as the lady. I was basically picturing that girl from The Ring, with the hair who crawls out of your TV, the whole time. EEK. Then the supporting characters who hang out in the slag heap, they’re like the people in Corpse Bride who are dead. Creepy, friend, creepy!

I think if YA absolutely must focus on boys, or increase the focus, then I would hope boy characters like Mackie come to the forefront, as I thought he was fully-realized and able to have emotions and to hug his male friends without being called names.

Other Reviews:

Steph Su Reads

Imagination In Focus

The Bibliophilic Book Blog

Purchase The Replacement Here

The following two tabs change content below.
April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.
About April (Books&Wine)

April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.


  1. I think this one looks creepy too… I love the cover! This one has been on my Wish List for awhile now…

    Great review!

  2. I have this to read. I’m so looking forward to it. Thanks for the great review.
    Lisa ~ YA Literature Lover

  3. I loved Mackie too. I loved that he wasn’t the standard golden boy or poor misunderstood soul who didn’t want to fit in. He seemed like a real honest to God teenager who is kind of awkward and weird, who wants to fit in but isn’t really sure how much or if it’s really right once he does. The dark spookey stuff was fantastic too – a real old fashioned ghost/ghoul story, so refreshing.

  4. This sounds like the perfect book to read around Halloween! I always try to read books around hollidays that pertain to them. Thanks for the great review April! :]

  5. I read this one a while ago and did so purely because of the creepy cover. The book was pretty good – didn’t quite like the ending, but it didn’t ruin the experience for me. Way outside of my normal reading tastes but was great for me!

  6. Rarely do I judge a book by its cover, but I do like this cover. I don’t know why. I don’t know if I’ll ever have time to get to this book, though I do want to read a few YA titles. This may just be one of them.

  7. This definitely sounds like my kind of book!

  8. I’ve never heard of this book before, but now I can’t wait to read it. It looks awesome!


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Smash Attack Reads!, April C. April C said: 'The Replacement is legitimately creepy and not contrived creepy' @brennayovanoff @penguinteen […]

  2. […] Space Between by Brenna Yovanoff – I enjoyed The Replacement so I am willing to give this a […]

  3. […] best argument possible without going all flailing arms and neon signs on you? You guys, I liked The Replacement, but I utterly LOVED Paper Valentine. I found myself highlighting passages on my Kindle, and […]