Sarah’s Key by Tatiana De Rosnay is a historical fiction novel that follows the interweaving stories of Sarah Starzynski and Julia Jaramond. Sarah is a young Jewish girl who was taken from her Parisan home during the Vel d’Hiv round up. Julia Jaramond is an American journalist living in Paris who comes across Sarah’s story sixty years later.
I felt the idea behind Sarah’s Key was excellent, but the execution left something to be desired. I enjoyed the parts which pertained to Sarah, her story was fascinating. The parts which dealt with Julia seemed to come from a different book. Certain parts definitely seemed forced, like when the author introduced a character,Amelie, out of the blue. Really, this character had little purpose, I felt she could have been cut from the story and it probably would have made the book better.
I find characterization to be an incredibly important factor in my enjoyment of a book. InSarah’s Key, I felt most of the characters were flat. Julia’s a journalist with a heart but zero personality, her daughter Zoe is perfect, her husband Bertrand might as well be Pepe Le Pew. Boring. The only intriguing character was Sarah, I felt devastated as I read her sections. Her character was the only one who made me actually feel something. I don’t think it’s too much to ask that I feel something for a books characters, even contempt.
I understand the difficulty in rating a book pertaining to the Holocaust. If I rate a book too low, it sends the message that I don’t care about the Holocaust, when I really honestly do care. I think it’s important to Never Forget. Rosnay’s purpose in writing Sarah’s Key, I believe was to bring to light the heartbreaking Vel d’Hiv’ round-up and the complicity of the French. I applaud her purpose, I just wish this book had been more well-written.
Other reviews of Sarah’s Key by Tatiana De Rosnay:
- The Whimsy Bookworm – “The writing was good too as was the pace of the book“
- The Lit Bitch – “I struggled with Julia’s character“
- Mom’s Small Victories – “It makes a great book club book“
Preview or Purchase Sarah’s Key:
Latest posts by April (Books&Wine) (see all)
- For The Love Of The Bard by Jessica Martin | Book Review - July 1, 2022
- A Few Books I Recently Read - June 22, 2022
- A Mirror Mended by Alix E. Harrow | Novella Review - June 14, 2022
I bought this for my mom because she is interested in teh Holocaust and had been saying she wanted to read more about it. Paid full price and everything, so I am kinda disappointed that the execution is poor, because that's a big no-no for me. Hmm…
Also:
I don't think rating a Holocaust book low makes you seem insensitive. I think it makes you look thoughtful and sure enough of your own intelligence that you're not going to be cowed by anyone into watering down your analysis of someone's WRITING. And I think that people that try to guilt someone into puffing up their critiques through intimidation and sentimentality should go back to their corners. =P