When You Were Mine Rebecca Serle Audiobook Review

We all know the story of Romeo and Juliet — heck I had to read it in high school – but what about the minor characters? Rebecca Serle examines the character of Rosaline, Romeo’s love interest pre-Juliet against the modern backdrop of high school in Southern California. When You Were Mine is a heartbreaking read that will eventually put those pieces of your heart back together.

When You Were Mine Rebecca Serle Audiobook Cover

When You Were Mine

Rosaline grew up next door to Rob Montag. He left for the summer right, but before leaving he kissed her. Due to the his, Rosaline thinks as a senior her and Robb will finally hook up the way it is meant to be. Her best friends Charlie and Olivia will rule the school with her. In short, it will be the best year ever. These plans come crashing down when Rosaline’s cousin Juliet comes back to town and takes more than a friendly interest in Robb.

I think that the mark of a strong story for me is that I am riveted and hoping against hope, even if I know how the story is going to end. We all know the outcome of Romeo and Juliet and you guys I wanted SO badly for Robb to see how much Juliet sucks and to date Rosaline instead. Sigh. But we all know that definitely does not happen. And I was practically shouting and muttering at the book because hey, I might be able to change the outcome. Alas. That did not happen.

The characters in When You Were Mine are very well drawn. Rosaline is so vulnerable. I like that because Rebecca Serle writes in first person, we don’t have a huge wall up around Rosaline. I feel like I know her. Plus, she’s easy to relate to. I think we all know what it’s like to have a crush on or be attracted to someone and then shot down because something more attractive comes along. Serle captures that sort of pain and angst, perfectly. Yet she also shows growth with Rosaline. We see Rosaline learn that you can’t pin all your hopes on one guy and that there are indeed, other fish in the sea.

I also loved reading about Rosaline’s friends Charlie and Olivia who reminded me of my friends. Charlie is bossy and totally the HBIC. Olivia is gorgeous and a total ditz. Yet when push comes to shove, they have got Rosaline’s back. I love that they aren’t perfect people, but they are damn good friends. To me, this is admirable — this group of people who support each other and are not backbiting or betrayers.

I listened to the audiobook version of When You Were Mine which is read by Sarah Grace and produced by Brilliance Audio. It is pretty short, only 7 hours and 54 minutes unabridged. I quite liked Sarah Grace’s soft and vulnerable voicing for the most part. However I was not a huge fan of her male voices and especially her performance of Rosaline’s potential love interest. Seriously, she made him sound like a mouth breather which is gross. That stated, this is actually a pretty decent audiobook and a good one if you want to check When You Were Mine out and have a good commute. I actually liked listening to it while going on walks.

Disclosure: Purchased copy.

Other reviews of When You Were Mine by Rebecca Serle:

Makeshift Bookmark – “My pitchfork hand was getting a little stabby

Rather Be Reading – “I was fully invested in the story almost instantaneously

Paranormal Indulgence – “Serle is the painter who does extraordinary things with the smallest, thinnest brush

Chick Loves Lit – “It is an interesting sensation to nearly instantly hate Juliet.

The following two tabs change content below.
April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.
About April (Books&Wine)

April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.


  1. Lovely review! I’ve heard lots of good things about this. I need to read it! 🙂

  2. Bahahah mouth breather. But that is really unfortunate, given that he is a pretty big part of the book 🙁 That would be so distracting. In one of the audiobooks I listened to, the male sounded like a teenage Eeyore. Seriously. The one downfall to having just one gender read the audiobooks.

  3. I got a copy of this from Amazon Vine, not realizing it was a reworking of Romeo and Juliet. I’m very curious to learn more about Rosaline and her new love interest as well as how Rob and Juliet speed toward death.

  4. I so want to read this book after reading this review. Def it’s my cup of tea. Thank you for this post 🙂

  5. Oh, I could NOT agree more about the whole hoping against hope that the story would change for us. I didn’t want to believe that Serle had gone there with these characters. I thought for sure Rob would see the light. Alas, I was disappointed. Great review – definitely cracked up at the whole mouth-breathing thing re: Len’s parts. Hahaha. Very good to know!

  6. I absolutely love the premise of the story and definitely want to give it a shot. Is it bad that when I think of Romeo and Juliet I automatically think of Leonardo DeCaprio lol… (probably, but I’ll admit it anyways)

  7. Thanks for the review. I confess I’m not a big fan of Romeo and Juliet – I kind of hate the play, actually, but I like the sound of this take. Rosalie sounds like a great character! 😀

  8. This sounds fantastic! I’m a huge fan of ‘Shakespeare Revisited’ types of things. Great review! 😉

  9. I’ve been trying to get into When You Were Mine, but I keep losing interest. I can’t explain why either, which always bothers me. I have an account with Audible, so I think I might download the audio to see if that works better for me. Hopefully I can get past the mouth breathing! 🙂

  10. I feel like the biggest grouch in the world, but this book didn’t do it for me! It’s not that I wanted Rob with anyone else, I just thought Rosaline was a little… mopey? Like 4/5 of the book moping and 1/5 recovering, when I’d prefer more of a 2/3 to 1/3 ratio? Does that make any sense? Maybe my expectations were just too high. Here’s my review for the counter: http://mysistersbookshelf.com/marys-book-review-when-you-were-mine-by-rebecca-serles/

  11. Ohhh this sounds really interesting. R&J always bothered me for obvious reasons, and I love Shakespeare reimagenings, so I might check this one out. 🙂

  12. Loved Romeo and Juliet, so I have a feeling that I’ll love this book. It sounds like it was definitely a good read (or listen!)