The Holders Julianna Scott Book Review

Are you looking for a young adult fantasy with a fiercely protective main character, an interesting magic system and zOMG Celtic mythology? Then you really ought to preorder The Holders by Julianna Scott because it is brimming with the fantastic. PLUS! There is kissing! And family secrets! And and and UNRESOLVED FEELINGS! HOLLA! Y’all, I cannot wait for you to read this so we can talk about it a little tiny bit more in depth and we can discuss how much we’d love to buy main character Becca a drink and how cool it would be to be a Holder.

The Holders Julianna Scott Book Cover

Becca is the quintessential overprotective older sister. Her brother Ryland has a few problems, you see he hears voices. It’s an issue that’s gotten him into school trouble and makes being around other people kind of awkward. When two mysterious dudes show up and tell Becca that her brother Ryland has a gift and that there’s a school that can help him in Ireland — Becca is all OVER MY DEAD BODY. But, then she relents when one of the guys, Alex, explains that Ryland is part of a race known as the Holders, people who have magical powers. The problem? The school they want to send Ryland to is run by Becca and Ryland’s estranged father. And so, Becca who graduated high school early decides to accompany Ryland. Y’all, some cray cray surprises go down and yes, if you like your books full of drama, The Holders has drama in spades.

Pretty much Becca is the sort of main character that I LOVE reading about. Sure, she does some things that are totally irritating, but on the whole I liked her. As I stated above, Becca is very protective of her little brother. I love that. I love that she will throw down for her family regardless of consequences. Becca is also a bit of a whiz kid, in that she graduated high school three years early but has put off college to take care of her family. I love that while her relationship with her dad is kind of whack, she’s got such a loving relationship with her mother and brother. ALSO! She’s totally stubborn and hotheaded and as someone who is also hotheaded, I could totally relate and pump my fist a little whenever her stubbornness proved correct.

Scott’s writing style is pretty easy to get into. She throws in some Celtic terms and phrases, but it’s nothing that threw me for a loop or out of the book. I felt that The Holders was fast paced once I got into it. However, it took me like 3 chapters to really get into it. Like, I thought the beginning when we are finding out about the school and Ryland’s abilities were kind of awkward and a little fast — like I would have liked more of a background in Becca’s life before she heads out to Ireland.

However, what I thought was particularly well done was the world building and the magical systems. The Holders are people who each have a special magical power. Now, each person only has one power and isn’t a super hero or anything. ALSO each power comes with a weakness. I thought the weakness of each person was a bit too easily overcome, but still at least they aren’t invincible or anything. I liked that the different powers made it so that various Holders had to work together, no one person can do everything.

Probably my biggest complaint about The Holders is that the relationship within it is very insta-love-esque. I would have liked a longer development of feelings and tingles between Becca and her love interest. I just thought they fell in love WAY too fast and rather than be swoon worthy, I was kind of nonchalant in my feelings towards the relationship. With all of the fantastic going on magicwise, I would have liked the relationship to be more realistic, ya know? That said, their kissing scenes are pretty adorable.

For the most part, The Holders by Julianna Scott is a solid debut with a fantastical premise set in a land that totally does evoke magic. The writing is decent, never boring or overwrought. However, the romance felt a little shaky. In all, I do recommend this book to people who are all about the fantasy rather than to people who are all about the hook ups.

Disclosure: Received for review

Other reviews of The Holders by Julianna Scott:

I haven’t seen any at the time of writing this — like 2 months before it’s scheduled ha ha. Leave me a link in the comments if you’ve reviewed this.

The following two tabs change content below.
April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.
About April (Books&Wine)

April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.


  1. This sounds like something I will love! I’ve been a little hesitant to start this one, but I’m excited now! Kind of fascinated with the idea of each of their powers coming with a weakness..that’s definitely unique! And I’m definitely up for something with great world-building. Sounds awesome.

    • Becky, The Holders is pretty good — I read a very, very early version of it, like a pre-ARC copy so I would imagine that it is even better now.

      For sure, I feel like we hear too much about powers making a character invincible and I just prefer it when there’s some sort of weakness there.

      Hope you love The Holders when you read it. 🙂

  2. Yay! I am planning to start this one this week. All the reviews have been so positive, I’m excited to try it 🙂

  3. I read The Holders two months ago, so I’m so glad it’s close to the release date and people are actually posting reviews! I loved it. I agree that the relationship was very “insta-love,” even though Scott gives a sort of explanation for it. Now I just want to go away to boarding school in Ireland so I can hang around St. Brigid’s. They have some college classes there, right?

    • Me too, I am so glad to see more and more reviews go up.

      It’s good that she explained why instead of just leaving it at a mysterious attraction.

      They do have college classes. Let’s all go to St. Brigid’s hahaha.

  4. I too like the idea that with the strength comes a weakness – that’s kinda different. Also I like that they have to work together because everyone has only one power? I can certainly see some originality here in the magic, which is really cool. I can overlook well-done insta-love if there are other cool things to be found. I hadn’t heard of this one before, so thanks for putting it on my radar, April. Sounds fun.

    • Yeah — I am so used to books where characters seem almost invincible because of their powers, so this is quite a nice change.

      Yes! They do have to work together. It’s a very unique magic system.

      Hope you like The Holders should you decide to read it. 🙂

  5. So excited about reading this! Really need to get on it!

  6. I can’t believe I’ve never heard of this book! It sounds so much like something I’d really enjoy, even if the romance is insta-lovey. The magical aspects sound interesting, and I’m always down for Celtic things. Adding it to the TBR!

  7. I think one of the most magical words for me when it comes to book is FANTASY. Based on your review, this sounds like a solid one. I’m loving that Celtic mythology is involved, and I’m loving that it’s set partly in IRELAND (which is a place I’ve always wanted to visit). As a huge fantasy fan, I absolutely cannot wait to read this!


  1. […] yes, Celtic Inspired fantasy! Or a review of THE HOLDERS by Julianna […]