The Wise Man’s Fear Patrick Rothfuss Book Review

You know that awkward moment when you totally build the highly anticipated sequel up in your head and then you read the sequel and it does not quite live up to your expectations? That is exactly how I felt with The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss, sequel to The Name Of The Wind, a book so awesome I read it twice — once in print and once via audio.  I had hoped to fall madly in love with The Wise Man’s Fear after waiting so long for it, but instead I was like, hmmm that was REALLY good, but I don’t love it. It’s no Prada backpack, merely Sketcher’s (+1 if you get the reference).

The Wise Man's Fear Patrick Rothfuss Book Cover

As it has been since March of 2011, when I read The Wise Man’s Fear, my plot summary is going to be kind of rusty ha ha. Okay, so you know how Ambrose is a total douche? Well, him and Kvothe still do not get along at all. They have this major rivalry which ends up with Kvothe getting expelled from the university. Kvothe then decides to go to Vintas. There he gets involved with the court and becomes kind of a big deal. THEN he gets involved with the Adem, who are mercenaries. AND THEN lots and lots of things happen and pretty much we start hearing how those legends surround Kvothe happened.

While Kvothe does seem to grow in Rothfuss’s sophomore effort, it wasn’t quite enough to put me in crazed fangirl territory. I liked reading about all of the things that he learns from the various cultures he visits. Yet, he’s still kind of perfect, ya feel me? Like, instead of being sexed to death by this fairy-God, he handles her despite being a virgin. Instead of being killed by the Adem, he ends up joining them. He always seems the get the best of most situations. I mean, it’s cool, but sometimes I just want a situation to get the best of him or for a solution to take a little bit longer to happen.

I did enjoy the additional worldbuilding in The Wise Man’s Fear. Straight up, Vintas is awesome. There is SO MUCH INTRIGUE I CANNOT EVEN. I also liked the bits with the Adem, because they are mercenaries who speak with hand gestures. Plus, the Adem are totally open about sex and what not. Their culture is bombass, in the best possible way. I just loved all the extra touches Rothfuss puts in his worlds.

For the most part, The Wise Man’s Fear moves as smoothly as The Name Of The Wind. Rothfuss is a fabulous wordsmith, at least in my opinion. It’s a very, very long book and it could have ended up being really boring, but instead is packed with action and lots of new information. I don’t find Rothfuss’s prose to be bloated in the least. Nor was I all like, for the love of god, do we have to read about some more trees. Although, there is a lot of traveling in this book, so take that as you will.

However, the pacing was rather uneven. There were some portions where I just tore through the book. But, there were also parts were I was all can we please just get on with it. For example, I thought The Wise Man’s Fear really dragged with Felurian. Maybe I am a little bit prude, but I was like can we please stop sexing and go back to looking for the Chandrian, or back the university? I know, I know, you would think I would be the last one to say that. Yet, I think Rothfuss is at his best when he’s describing the university and the interactions between Kvothe, his friends, and awful Ambrose.

Despite my not being head over heels in love with The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss, I will be back for the third book and will probably pay whatever kindle price they charge just to have it download instantly at midnight. I will also probably attempt a re-read via audiobook as Nick Poedhl is my king. I am kind of hoping I fall IN LOVE-LOVE with the audiobook version. That stated, I would recommend this with the caveat that if you loved The Name Of The Wind and are desperate to know what happens next, you should read this, but don’t expect lightening to strike twice.

Disclosure: Purchased copy (twice, once on my kindle AND the hard cover version)

Other reviews of The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss:

The Allure Of Books – “Ridiculous amounts of gushing to follow.

Steph Su Reads – “as meticulously plotted and beautifully written as the first.

Fyrefly’s Book Blog – “There are books that sweep me away as soon as I open their pages, and there are books that keep me enthralled for hundreds of pages

The following two tabs change content below.
April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.
About April (Books&Wine)

April is in her 30s and created Good Books And Good Wine. She works for a non-profit. April always has a book on hand. In her free time she can be found binge watching The Office with her husband and toddler, spending way too much time on Pinterest or exploring her neighborhood.


  1. Bummer you didn’t love this one as much! NotW is definitely still #1 in my heart, but I fell for this one too. The only part I didn’t like was one you mentioned – the weird faerie smexing. That part was bizarre.

    I so cannot wait for the last installment! Chandrian! The assumed king killing! Ahhhh!

    Also, I’m very impressed by the detail of your review considering how long ago you read the book.

  2. I just listened to The Wise Man’s Fear–Nick Podehl is AMAZE–and I enjoyed it. It was a little long in some parts, and I am very nearly over Kvothe and his ladies: the whole Denna thing drives me batty, and the parts with Fellurian smacked a little of teenage boy sex fantasy or something. BUT. I love Kvothe to the ends of the earth, and I can’t wait to get book three. I don’t mind a good road trip, but I’m REALLY excited to get back to the University. And to the Chandrian, hello! They were hardly in this book. I feel like Kvothe is nearing a breakthrough about them. Well, I HOPE he is.
    Also, HOLLA 10 Things I Hate About You! (Right? I swear that’s where that Prada/Sketchers thing is from!)

  3. Great review! I still haven’t read the first one. It’s literally #1 on my TBR, but I haven’t gotten to it yet. Glad you still liked it pretty well. I hate that when your expectations are too high and you don’t like it as much as you thought. I think I do that more with films than with books, but still. Anyway, thanks for the review. Have a great weekend! 😀 P.S. Reference is 10 Things I Hate About You. Love that movie! 😀

  4. Girl, your energy just makes me laugh! I have no idea what this series is, but now I want to know! Thanks for the share 😉

  5. I have the first one, am determined to get the second one and I will read it! Eventually. Love the review though. It lets me know what to expect.

  6. BAHAHA, love that reference. 😀

    Also, I do this to myself with sequels all the time. I’m sometimes not sure if they’re actually less good or if I’m just not in the right mood or if I’ve overhyped myself. I did that with Scorch by Gina Damico. Like, still really funny, but I didn’t feel as in love with it. Sigh.

  7. So what you’re saying is that you were whelmed by this book?

    I agree, though I think I did end up liking this more than you, I didn’t LOVE it the way I loved the first one. I totally paid that ridiculous release day instant-download price though, and I’ll do it again.


  1. […] I posted a long stewing review of The Wise Man’s Fear by Patrick Rothfuss and decide it’s more like a pair of Sketchers than a Prada […]

  2. […] one of my favorite characters ever, Kvothe, and while I was not one hundred percent in love with The Wise Man’s Fear, The Name of The Wind remains one of my favorite fantasy recommendations and audiobooks. And you […]